Energy scenarios for Poland-a comparison of PRIMES and TIMES-PL modeling results

Artur Wyrwa, Adam Szurlej, Lidia Gawlik, Wojciech Suwała

Abstract


The aim of this paper was to compare the results of energy scenarios, which were prepared by the use of PRIMES and TIMES-PL energy models for Poland. Both models have been designed for modelling the mid- and long-term development of the energy system. The paper briefly describes the PRIMES and TIMES methodology explaining both the similarities and differences of approaches in relation to modelling the power supply. Four scenarios were analysed in this study: (i) PRIMES-REF, (ii) TSAP-REF, (iii) TIMES-REF, (iv) TIMES-NUC. Although these scenarios were elaborated with the use of different modelling tools there are many analogies in the evolution of the Polish power system up to 2050. As a consequence of EU climate policy and rising carbon prices within the European Union's Emissions Trading System (ETS) we observe a fuel and technology switch towards less carbon intensive options in all scenarios. The comparison is most adequate with PRIMES-REF and TIMES-NUC due to them having the best match in modelling assumptions and input parameters. In both, electricity generation from solid fuel declines throughout the projection period. This decline is more sharp before 2030 and stabilises thereafter. The relative share of fuels in the electricity generation mix by 2050 is not much different in both scenarios. Solid fuels constitute more than 45 %. The biggest differences were found in gas, nuclear, wind and solar. The differences for nuclear, wind and solar can be explained by the system-wide constraints applied in TIMES-PL. Increased use of gas in PRIMES-REF is presumably more of a methodological nature. CO2 emissions have a similar, decreasing trend reaching ca. 45 Mt in 2050. In both scenarios ca. 39 % of electricity generated in thermal power plants in 2050 comes from units equipped with Carbon Capture and Storage (CCS). The study confirmed the robustness of the TIMES-PL model and showed that it can be used to provide valuable insights contributing to the development of Polish energy policy.


Keywords


power system; modelling; energy security; TIMES-PL; PRIMES; Poland

Full Text:

PDF

References


EC: EU Energy, Transport And Ghg Emissions Trends To 2050. Reference Scenario 2013. E3M-Lab, IIASA, EuroCARE Luxenburg, 2014.

Gawlik, L., (ed): Coal for Polish energy sector in 2050 perspective – scenario analyses. Mining Chamber of Industry and Commerce, Wydawnictwo Instytutu Gospodarki Surowcami Mineralnymi i Energią PAN, p. 1-299, Katowice, 2013 (in Polish).

Wyrwa, A., Pluta, M., Skoneczny, S., and Mirowski, T., Modelling the Mid-term Development of an Energy System with the use of a Technology Explicit Partial Equilibrium Model [in:] E-science on Distributed Computing Infrastructure: PLGrid Plus2014, Springer-Verlag GmbH. p. 489-503.

Capros, P., et al., Description of models and scenarios used to assess European decarbonisation pathways. Energy Strategy Reviews, 2(3–4)2014, p. 220-230.

Loulou, R., ETSAP-TIAM: The TIMES integrated assessment model. Part II: Mathematical formulation. Computational Management Science, 5(1-2)2008, p. 41-66.

Vaillancourt, K., Labriet, M., Loulou, R., and Waaub, J.-P., The role of nuclear energy in long-term climate scenarios: An analysis with the World-TIMES model. Energy Policy, 36(7)2008, p. 2296-2307.

Capros, P., et al., Analysis of the EU policy package on climate change and renewables. Energy Policy, 39(3)2011, p. 1476-1485.

Fragkos, P., Kouvaritakis, N., and Capros, P., Model-based analysis of the future strategies for the MENA energy system. Energy Strategy Reviews, 2(1)2013, p. 59-70.

Cosmi, C., et al., A model for representing the Italian energy system: The NEEDS-TIMES experience. Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews, 13(4)2009, p. 763-776.

Amann, M., et al., Cost-effective control of air quality and greenhouse gases in Europe: Modeling and policy applications. Environmental Modelling and Software, 26(12)2011, p. 1489-1501.

Wyrwa, A., Pluta, M., and Zyśk, J. Modeling the mid-term development of the energy system in Poland with the use of TIMES-PL model. ENERDAY conference on energy economics and technology: energy policies and market design in Europe, Dresden, 2013.

Kannan, R. and Turton, H., A Long-Term Electricity Dispatch Model with the TIMES Framework. Environmental Modeling and Assessment, 18(3)2013, p. 325-343.

ECMWF: Provides medium-range weather forecast support to European meteorological organizations.

JRC: Photovoltaic Geographical Information System. 2013.

DAS: Optimal Polish energy mix by 2060, 2013, Strategic Analysis Department, Chancellery of the Prime Minister of Poland, Warsaw, 2013 (in Polish).

EPRI: Program on Technology Innovation: Electricty Use in the Electric Sector. Opportunities to Enhance Electric Energy Efficiency in the Production and Delivery of Electricty. Electric Power Research Institute, Palo Alto, 2011.

Suwala, W., Modelling adaptation of the coal industry to sustainability conditions. Energy, 33(7)2008, p. 1015-1026.

European Commission, Energy Road map 2050. Impact Assessment, SEC(2011) 1565/2, ed. C.S.W. Paper, 2011.

Szurlej, A. and Janusz, P., Natural gas economy in the United States and European markets. Gospodarka Surowcami Mineralnymi - Mineral Resources Management, 29(4)2013, p. 77–94


Refbacks

  • There are currently no refbacks.